Most Valuable U.S. Coins That Collectors Go Crazy For

Coin collecting is more than just a hobby—it’s a journey through American history. From rare mint errors to limited-edition releases, some U.S. coins are worth far more than their face value. These valuable treasures are sought after by collectors worldwide, and a few can even fetch six or seven figures at auction.

Whether it’s the elusive 1913 Liberty Head Nickel or the iconic 1804 Silver Dollar, these coins spark excitement and competition among enthusiasts. In this blog, we’ll explore the most valuable U.S. coins that collectors go crazy for—coins that have become legends in the world of numismatics. If you’re a beginner or seasoned collector, knowing which coins are truly worth something could change your collection forever. Read on to discover which rare coins could be hiding in your change jar—or waiting to be the crown jewel of your collection.

5 Most Valuable U.S. Coins

Even though the United States is relatively young compared to other nations, some of its rare coins are worth astonishing sums—often rivaling or exceeding the value of collectible coins from older countries.

In fact, five of the world’s ten most valuable coins were minted in the U.S. Let’s take a closer look at these extraordinary pieces and discover why they are worth so much.

5. 1913 Liberty Head Nickel

Sold at auction: $4.56 million

Only five Liberty Head Nickels were produced in 1913, making them extremely rare and highly desirable to collectors. The coin that fetched $4.56 million at a 2018 auction is the most valuable of its kind. It was first acquired by Louis E. Eliasberg Sr. in 1948 and is often called the Eliasberg specimen. Its highly reflective surface gives it the appearance of a proof coin.

Of the remaining four coins, two are now in public collections. The McDermott specimen, once carried around in the owner’s pocket, is the least well-preserved and is now displayed at the ANA Money Museum in Colorado Springs. Another, known as the Norweb coin, is housed at the Smithsonian Institution.

Interestingly, this 1913 nickel was the first coin to cross the $1 million mark at auction back in 1996.

4. 1794 Flowing Hair Silver Dollar

Sold at auction: $4,993,750

Minted in 1794, this coin represents the first U.S. silver dollar and is among the oldest American currency pieces in existence. Only one die variety was used that year before it was retired.

One of the most notable surviving examples spent nearly 170 years stored in a Chippendale cabinet once owned by Lord St. Oswald. It’s also one of just six known examples that have been professionally graded.

This coin stands out because the first three stars are fully visible and the Liberty image is sharply defined, suggesting it came from an early strike before the die showed signs of wear.

3. 1787 Brasher Doubloon, EB Punch on Wing

Private sale: Over $5,000,000

The oldest coin on the list, the 1787 Brasher Doubloon, was created by goldsmith Ephraim Brasher, who lived next door to George Washington in post-Revolution New York City.

Each doubloon bears Brasher’s “EB” initials. Of the seven known examples, six—including this one—have the hallmark stamped on the eagle’s wing. This particular coin is considered the finest example of them all.

2. 1933 Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle

Sold at auction: $7,590,020

In 1933, President Franklin D. Roosevelt ordered that nearly all $20 Saint-Gaudens gold coins be melted down before they were made legal tender—except for two that were preserved for the Smithsonian.

Nevertheless, several coins managed to escape the melting process. Nine were later confiscated by the Secret Service, while another coin made its way into the collection of King Farouk of Egypt. After his collection was auctioned in 1954, the coin vanished until it resurfaced in 1995 with British dealer Stephen Fenton.

A legal dispute ensued, and the coin was ultimately sold with proceeds shared between Fenton and the U.S. government. Its current owner has chosen to remain anonymous and reportedly isn’t even a coin enthusiast.

1. 1794 Flowing Hair Silver Dollar

Sold at auction: $10,016,875

This version of the 1794 Flowing Hair Silver Dollar, rated “Specimen,” is believed to be one of the first examples struck—possibly a test piece from the U.S. Mint. This would explain its exceptionally sharp details and flawless strike.

Unlike later examples, which show signs of die wear and misalignment, this coin is free from imperfections caused by repeated use of the dies, making it one of the most historically and visually significant coins in American numismatics.

Bottom Line

The world of coin collecting is filled with hidden gems and historical riches. Some U.S. coins have become legendary due to their rarity, minting errors, or historical significance—making them incredibly valuable to collectors. Whether you’re hoping to cash in on a lucky find or searching for that one special coin to complete your set, understanding what makes certain coins so desirable is essential. Keep an eye on your spare change; you might just stumble upon a small fortune. Remember, in coin collecting, knowledge is as valuable as the coins themselves.

FAQs